Why Should You Self-Publish Your Fantasy Book?

Picture of Sarah Beer
Sarah Beer
content writer @Spines
Contents

In the dynamic world of book publishing, authors of fantasy literature face a crucial decision: whether to self-publish or pursue traditional publishing routes. Traditional publishing involves partnering with established publishing houses that manage the editorial, production, and marketing processes, often requiring the intermediary role of a literary agent. This route can offer extensive distribution and professional guidance but often at the cost of creative control and financial returns.

Conversely, self-publishing has become a popular choice among fantasy authors looking to maintain creative control and directly engage with their readers. It empowers authors to take full control of their creative work, from cover art to pricing and distribution. Key terms such as “Kindle Direct Publishing,” “print on demand,” and “online retailers” are central to this approach, reflecting the modern channels through which authors can independently release and manage their books. Particularly in the fantasy genre, self-publishing allows writers to explore niche markets and cater to specific reader interests that traditional publishers might deem too risky or non-mainstream.

The allure of self-publishing in the fantasy sector has grown significantly, driven by success stories of authors who have cultivated dedicated readerships and achieved commercial success outside the traditional frameworks. This growth is underscored by the genre’s creative demands, including extensive world-building and character development, which thrive under the bespoke approach offered by self-publishing. This sector’s expansion indicates a vibrant future where more authors can present their unique visions directly to an eager audience, challenging the conventional pathways and reshaping the landscape of fantasy literature.

The Rise of Self-Publishing in Fantasy Literature

The advent of self-publishing has revolutionized the literary world, democratizing the process of publishing and enabling authors to take the helm of their creative destinies. Historically, self-publishing was often seen as a last resort for authors unable to secure contracts with traditional publishers. However, the evolution of digital technologies and the Internet has transformed it into a first choice for many, particularly in the fantasy genre.

Initially, self-publishing was synonymous with substantial upfront costs, including expenses for print runs and distribution. This changed drastically with the rise of digital platforms and print-on-demand technology. Services like Amazon Kindle Direct Publishing (KDP), Smashwords, and Draft2Digital have allowed authors to publish at minimal costs with global distribution potentials. These platforms handle everything from printing to delivering eBooks and paperbacks directly to consumers, bypassing traditional distribution channels.

Fantasy literature, in particular, has seen a significant surge in self-publishing. The genre’s inherent requirement for extensive world-building and character depth makes it uniquely suited to the freedoms of self-publishing. Authors are no longer confined by the genre constraints or marketability concerns of traditional publishers. They can explore intricate plot lines, develop vast, detailed universes, and target niche audiences who crave such depth and complexity.

The impact of platforms like Amazon KDP on the fantasy genre cannot be overstated. Amazon’s algorithms, which favor customer preferences and reading habits, have allowed fantasy books to reach audiences that traditional publishers might never have targeted. This level of accessibility has been a game-changer, enabling fantasy novels to climb bestseller lists and achieve visibility in a crowded marketplace. Self-publishing fantasy on platforms like Amazon KDP has revolutionized the genre by providing fantasy authors with the tools to directly reach their target audience, overcoming challenges specific to the fantasy genre such as the need for high-quality editing, captivating cover design, and effective marketing strategies, while also helping to erase the stigma once associated with self-published books.

Several successful self-published fantasy authors exemplify this shift. Perhaps the most notable is Amanda Hocking, who famously sold over a million copies of her books before signing with a traditional publisher. Her success story is not an isolated incident; authors like Michael J. Sullivan and Hugh Howey have also found tremendous success through self-publishing, leveraging their control over many aspects of the publishing process to build a strong reader base and enhance their careers.

Moreover, self-publishing has given rise to new stars within the fantasy realm, who have utilized the direct-to-reader model to foster a community of loyal fans. These authors often maintain creative control, publish on their own schedules, and build personal relationships with their audience through social media and independent marketing strategies.

In summary, the rise of self-publishing in fantasy literature is a testament to the shifting paradigms in the publishing industry. As digital platforms continue to evolve and the allure of creative and financial control grows stronger, more fantasy authors are likely to embrace self-publishing. This movement not only diversifies the types of stories available but also empowers authors to shape their careers on their own terms, leading to a richer and more varied literary landscape.

Benefits to Self-Publish Your Fantasy Book

The decision to self-publish a fantasy book brings with it a host of compelling advantages, particularly in the realms of creative and financial control, market responsiveness, audience targeting, and interactive feedback. One of the most compelling advantages is the potential for authors to join the ranks of successful self-publishers who have leveraged the benefits of self-publishing to achieve significant success in the fantasy genre. Each of these elements plays a critical role in why many fantasy authors are choosing the self-publishing route over traditional methods.

Creative Control

One of the most significant benefits of self-publishing is the unparalleled level of creative control it offers. This control extends across various aspects of the book creation process, from the intricacies of the plot to the nuances of character development and the artistic direction of cover design.

Cover Design: The cover of a book makes a critical first impression. Self-publishing allows authors to select their own cover artist or even design their own covers, ensuring the exterior reflects the story’s spirit. This is especially vital in the fantasy genre, where the cover needs to convey the unique atmosphere and setting of the book.

Plot and Character Development: Without the constraints of a traditional publisher’s expectations, self-published authors retain full authority over their stories. They can delve deep into complex world-building and elaborate plots that might be deemed too niche or risky by conventional publishers. For fantasy literature, where detailed lore and character arcs are crucial, this can enhance the richness and authenticity of the narrative.

Financial Benefits

Financially, self-publishing can be significantly more rewarding than traditional publishing paths. By bypassing the intermediary layers of publishers, agents, and distributors, self-published authors can earn higher royalties per book.

Higher Royalties: Whereas traditional publishing contracts typically offer authors royalties of around 10% to 15% on hardcovers, self-publishing platforms like Amazon Kindle Direct Publishing offer up to 70% on eBooks and competitive rates on print books. This substantial difference can lead to greater earnings from book sales.

Control Over Pricing: Self-published authors have the autonomy to set their own pricing strategies. This flexibility allows authors to adjust prices in response to market demands, promotional activities, or competitive positioning, which is particularly advantageous for authors experimenting with serial publications or box sets in the fantasy genre.

Speed to Market

In the traditional publishing world, the journey from manuscript to bookshelf can be lengthy—often taking 18 months to 2 years. Self-publishing, however, dramatically accelerates this timeline.

Bypassing Traditional Delays: With self-publishing, once the book is written, edited, and formatted, it can be made available for sale within days. This swift turnaround not only satisfies eager readers but also allows authors to capitalize on trends within the fantasy genre much more quickly.

Niche Markets

The fantasy genre is renowned for its variety of sub-genres and niche categories—from high fantasy and urban fantasy to steampunk and dark fantasy. Traditional publishers often overlook less popular niches due to perceived lower market potentials.

Targeting Specific Audiences: Self-publishing allows authors to tailor their work to specific segments of the fantasy market without concern for broad commercial appeal. This ability to serve dedicated niche audiences can build a devoted and engaged readership.

Use of Beta Readers and Direct Feedback Loops

Another strategic advantage of self-publishing is the ability to utilize beta readers and direct feedback mechanisms throughout the writing process.

Beta Readers: Authors can select a group of beta readers to provide feedback on early drafts. This process is invaluable for fantasy writers, who benefit from insights into their world-building, plot consistency, and character relatability before finalizing their manuscripts.

Feedback Loops: Direct interaction with readers through social media and reader forums allows authors to receive ongoing feedback. This can inform not only the current work in progress but also future projects. Such interaction helps authors refine their stories to better meet the expectations and preferences of their audience.

In conclusion, self-publishing offers fantasy authors numerous benefits that align well with the demands and creative aspirations of the genre. From having full creative freedom and obtaining higher financial returns to quickly responding to market trends and directly engaging with niche audiences, self-publishing presents a compelling case for authors ready to take the reins of their literary careers.

 Why Should You Self-Publish Your Fantasy Book?

Challenges of Self-Publishing

While self-publishing offers many benefits, it also comes with its own set of challenges. These include the need for significant

personal investment, difficulties in marketing and sales, limitations in distribution channels, and the hurdles of maintaining quality control. Each of these areas requires careful consideration and strategic planning by authors who choose to self-publish, especially in the fantasy genre.

Personal Investment: Time, Effort, and Money

Self-publishing requires a substantial personal commitment not only in terms of time and effort but also financially. 

Time and Effort: Unlike traditional publishing, where tasks such as editing, design, and marketing are handled by the publisher, self-publishing places all these responsibilities on the author. This means that authors must either develop skills in areas like marketing and book formatting or spend time finding and managing freelancers to handle these tasks.

Financial Investment: Upfront costs can be significant in self-publishing. While digital platforms have reduced the cost of entry, expenses related to professional editing, cover design, formatting, and initial marketing campaigns can add up. For fantasy authors, who may require intricate cover designs and extensive editing for complex world-building, these costs can be particularly high.

Marketing and Sales Challenges

Building an audience and managing book sales are among the most daunting challenges faced by self-published authors.

Building an Audience: Without the support of a traditional publisher’s marketing apparatus, self-published authors must carve out their own niche in the market. This involves not only identifying and reaching potential readers but also engaging them effectively to build a loyal fanbase.

Social Media and Advertising: Effective use of social media and digital advertising can be critical for success but requires a good grasp of online marketing strategies and tools. Fantasy authors need to create compelling content that highlights the unique aspects of their worlds and stories to stand out in a crowded marketplace.

Distribution Limitations

The choice of distribution channels significantly impacts the reach and sales of self-published books.

Online Retailers: While platforms like Amazon provide global reach, reliance on online retailers limits potential exposure in physical bookstores. This can be a drawback for fantasy books, which often benefit from the visual appeal of their covers in physical retail settings.

Brick and Mortar Stores: Gaining shelf space in traditional bookstores is often challenging for self-published authors due to the preference for traditionally published titles and the logistics involved in stocking and returns. This can limit the visibility and accessibility of self-published fantasy novels to broader audiences who frequent these venues.

Quality Control Challenges

Maintaining high standards of quality in all aspects of the book is critical for building credibility and achieving long-term success.

Professional Editing: Without the rigorous editing process provided by traditional publishers, self-published authors must find and invest in professional editors who can refine their manuscripts to a polished standard, which is crucial in fantasy literature with its complex narratives.

Design and Formatting: The design of the book cover and the interior formatting must be professionally done to ensure that the book competes favorably with traditionally published titles. Poor design and formatting can detract from the reader’s experience and diminish the perceived value of the book.

While self-publishing offers many opportunities, it also demands a high level of dedication and savvy from authors, particularly in the fantasy genre, where expectations for quality and immersion are exceptionally high. Overcoming these challenges requires a balanced approach of skill development, strategic investment, and thorough planning.

Comparing Traditional Publishing and Self-Publishing

In the literary world, navigating the traditional publishing landscape often involves the complex process of securing a traditional publishing contract. The decision between traditional publishing and self-publishing is pivotal. Each path offers unique advantages and comes with distinct challenges, particularly for fantasy authors whose works often require extensive investment in terms of world-building, character development, and audience engagement.

The resources and distribution networks of a traditional publishing house can offer advantages to fantasy authors that are difficult to replicate through self-publishing.

Gatekeeping by Traditional Publishers

One of the most significant aspects of traditional publishing is the gatekeeping role played by publishers. This refers to the selective process by which manuscripts are chosen for publication based on various criteria including market trends, perceived reader interest, and literary quality.

What Gets Published: Traditional publishers often prioritize projects that promise high commercial returns, which can be limiting for fantasy authors whose work may not align with current market trends or whose narratives push conventional boundaries.

Impact on Creative Freedom: This gatekeeping can stifle creativity, as publishers may require changes to a manuscript to make it more marketable. For authors devoted to originality and authenticity in their storytelling, this can be a significant drawback.

The Role of Literary Agents and Traditional Publishing Contracts

Navigating the traditional publishing landscape typically involves literary agents who act as intermediaries between authors and publishers.

Literary Agents: Agents provide invaluable assistance in refining manuscripts, pitching to publishers, and negotiating contracts. However, securing an agent is often a challenging and competitive process in itself, requiring authors to impress with query letters and sample chapters.

Traditional Publishing Contracts: These contracts can offer the benefit of advances against royalties, providing authors with some financial security before their book hits the shelves. However, contractual terms may also impose restrictions on rights, royalties, and creative control.

Advantages of Traditional Publishing

Despite these challenges, traditional publishing offers several significant advantages that can make it an attractive option for many authors.

Professional Editing: Publishers provide professional editing services that ensure manuscripts are polished, cohesive, and clear. This is particularly beneficial in the fantasy genre, where complex plots and extensive world-building demand precision and clarity.

Marketing and Publicity: Established publishers have comprehensive marketing and publicity capabilities that can significantly amplify a book’s reach. From organizing book tours to securing media coverage, these resources are often beyond the reach of individual authors.

Broader Distribution: Traditional publishers have established relationships with a wide network of retailers, both online and in physical stores. This broad distribution network increases the likelihood of a book being stocked in bookstores across the country and internationally, enhancing visibility and sales potential.

Why Some Authors Still Prefer the Traditional Route

Despite the rise of self-publishing, many authors continue to prefer the traditional route for several reasons:

Prestige and Validation: Being published by a renowned publishing house can lend a certain prestige and validation that is highly valued in literary circles. For many authors, this recognition is crucial for building a career in writing.

Support Infrastructure: The support system provided by a traditional publisher, from editing and design to marketing and distribution, can be incredibly valuable, especially for new authors who might be overwhelmed by the demands of self-publishing.

Focus on Writing: Traditional publishing allows authors to focus more on their writing and less on the business aspects of book publishing. This can be particularly appealing to those who prefer to concentrate solely on their creative processes.

Self-publishing offers freedom and potentially higher financial returns, traditional publishing continues to attract authors who seek professional editing, effective marketing, and broad distribution. Each path offers distinct advantages, and the choice largely depends on an author’s career goals, desired level of involvement in the publishing process, and the specific needs of their work, especially within the diverse and demanding realm of fantasy literature.

How to Successfully Self-Publish Your Fantasy Book

Self-publishing your fantasy book can be a rewarding journey, but success in this endeavor requires a well-thought-out strategy, from the initial drafting phase to the final steps of promotion and sales. Here’s a comprehensive step-by-step guide to help fantasy authors navigate the self-publishing process.

Step-by-Step Guide: From the First Draft to the Finished Product

  1. First Draft: Begin with your story idea and transform it into a complete first draft. Focus on building a compelling narrative and rich, immersive world.
  2. Revisions: After completing the first draft, enter the revision phase. This involves multiple rounds of edits to refine plot points, deepen character arcs, and enhance the setting.
  3. Beta Readers: Engage a group of trusted beta readers who are fans of the fantasy genre. Use their feedback to improve clarity, pacing, and engagement.
  4. Professional Editing: Hire a professional editor to polish your manuscript. This should ideally include developmental editing to address structural issues, copy editing for grammatical correctness, and proofreading.
  5. 5. Cover Design: Commission a professional cover designer who specializes in fantasy books. The cover should reflect the mood and theme of your book and appeal to fantasy readers.
  6. Formatting: Format your manuscript for both print and e-book formats. Ensure that the interior design is clean, readable, and professionally arranged.
  7. ISBN and Copyright: Obtain ISBNs for your different formats and register your copyright to protect your work.
  8. Publishing Platforms: Choose your publishing platforms, such as Amazon KDP, Barnes & Noble Press, or others that suit your distribution goals.

Key Aspects of Cover Art, Professional Editing, and Book Formatting

Cover Art: The cover is your first selling point. It should be visually striking and genre-appropriate, capable of drawing readers’ attention in a crowded marketplace.

Professional Editing: Essential for ensuring that your book meets professional standards, editing can significantly impact your book’s reception. It helps refine the complexity of fantasy narratives, ensuring coherence and engagement.

Book Formatting: Proper formatting is critical for readability. Pay special attention to font choices, spacing, and layout, particularly for the unique elements of fantasy such as maps and appendices.

Importance of Building an Online Presence

Websites and Social Media Accounts: Establish a professional author website and active social media profiles to connect with readers and promote your books.

Engagement with Book Bloggers and Writing Communities: Collaborate with book bloggers to generate reviews and buzz upon release. Participate in online writing communities to increase your visibility and network with other writers.

Strategies for Distribution

Print on Demand: Utilize print-on-demand services to offer physical copies without the need for a large upfront investment in inventory.

eBooks: Distribute your eBook across multiple platforms to reach a wider audience. Consider exclusive deals (like Amazon’s Kindle Unlimited) for periods to boost rankings and visibility.

Multi-Platform Availability: Ensure your book is available in as many formats as possible, including audio if feasible, to maximize your reach and cater to different reader preferences.

Networking and Promotion

Book Fairs and Conventions: Attend fantasy and book conventions to network with peers and connect with fans. These events are great for gaining exposure and promoting your book directly to fantasy enthusiasts.

Online Communities and Fan Interaction: Engage regularly with your readers through online platforms and social media. Organize virtual readings, Q&A sessions, and participate in discussions about the fantasy genre.

Leveraging Reviews: Encourage readers to leave reviews on major platforms. Positive reviews can significantly influence potential readers and improve your book’s visibility.

By following these steps and strategies, you can maximize your chances of success in the self-publishing world. It’s a path that requires considerable effort and persistence, but for many fantasy authors, the potential rewards—creative freedom, financial benefits, and direct reader engagement—make it a worthwhile endeavor.

Self-Publishing With Spines 

Spines is a cutting-edge publishing platform designed to streamline the self-publishing process with advanced technology. Offering a suite of AI-powered tools, Spines simplifies each step of bringing your book to market, from initial manuscript upload to global distribution. Here’s a straightforward guide on how to publish your work with Spines.

1. Manuscript Upload: Start by uploading your manuscript through the user-friendly Spines dashboard. As you enter details like your book’s title and author name, you also secure your work with an instant copyright protection certificate, ensuring your intellectual property is safeguarded from the outset.

2. Intuitive Cover Design: Next, focus on creating a powerful first impression with your book cover. Whether you have an existing design or need to create one from scratch, Spines’ AI-powered cover generator offers an array of easy-to-use tools to help you design the perfect cover, with no technical skills required.

3. Proofreading: Spines employs advanced AI to thoroughly check your manuscript for grammatical errors and suggest improvements, ensuring your text is polished and professional. For those who prefer a human touch, professional proofreading services are also available.

4. Formatting: Choose from various formatting options to beautify the interior of your book. Customize everything from the type styles for your initial paragraphs to the book’s overall physical appearance, including cover type and paper finish.

5. Audiobook Creation: If your publishing plan includes an audiobook, Spines’ state-of-the-art AI can generate one in your chosen voice. This step ensures that your story is not only read but also heard exactly as you envisioned.

6. Order Your Copies: Once everything is set, order the number of copies you want, specifying whether you need eBooks, print versions, or both. Spines handles all aspects of production and shipping, allowing you to relax as you await the arrival of your books.

7. Global Distribution: Finally, Spines takes charge of distributing your book worldwide. By optimizing metadata, your work is prepared for sale through major retailers like Amazon and Barnes & Noble, ensuring your story reaches not just bookshelves but hearts around the globe.

By following these steps with Spines, authors can efficiently navigate the self-publishing process, ensuring their fantasy tales are not only published but poised for success in the expansive world of literature. Sign up for free to start your journey today. 

Conclusion: Self-Publishing Your Fantasy Book

Self-publishing your fantasy book presents an exciting array of opportunities that cater to the unique needs of the genre and the aspirations of its authors. Throughout this discussion, we’ve explored the compelling advantages of self-publishing, including complete creative control over every element of the book, from the intricacies of world-building and character arcs to the critical aspects of cover design. Financial benefits also stand out, with higher royalties and direct control over pricing, allowing authors to reap the rewards of their efforts more fully.

Moreover, the speed to market and the ability to target niche markets are particularly advantageous in the fantasy genre, where audience tastes can be highly specific and varied. The direct feedback mechanisms available through self-publishing also empower authors to refine their work based on reader insights, enhancing the quality and impact of their narratives.

As you consider the path of self-publishing, it’s essential to weigh these benefits against the challenges and determine how they align with your personal goals and the specific demands of your work. The decision should be informed by a thorough understanding of both the opportunities and the obstacles inherent in the self-publishing process.

Embrace the empowerment that comes from publishing your own work. Self-publishing not only allows you to bring your unique vision to life without compromise but also creates a direct connection with your readers, building a community that celebrates and supports your creative journey. The satisfaction of managing your publishing journey, coupled with the joy of seeing your work resonate with readers, can make self-publishing a profoundly rewarding experience.

In the realm of fantasy, where the only limits are those of your imagination, self-publishing can be the key to unlocking the true potential of your storytelling prowess.

content writer @Spines
Sarah Beer, originally from Cape Town, enriches the Spines team with her background in marketing and real estate content creation. A passionate traveler with a love for writing, she blends professional expertise and personal experiences to produce engaging, accurate, and informative articles. Sarah’s dedication to thorough research ensures she connects meaningfully with readers.
Continue Reading
Related articles recommended by Spines

Every great children’s book starts with a spark—an idea that inspires smiles stirs imaginations, or warms hearts. Whether you’re a parent weaving bedtime stories, a teacher eager to inspire young minds, or a writer with a dream, creating a children’s book is one of the most rewarding ways to make...

It seems we’re all ears these days—literally. Audiobooks have swiftly transformed from a quirky alternative to a go-to experience of literature through listening. In 2022 alone, the Audio Publishers Association reported that audiobook revenue hit an impressive $1.8 billion in the U.S., marking a staggering 20% growth from the previous...

Any writer can commiserate: once you’ve toiled away at your book (through several edits and retooling of characters) to get your manuscript just right, there’s a limited amount of creative energy left in the reserve to tend to the list of other elements that need completion before your book is...

Let’s face it—our planet’s in trouble, and we all need to do our part. Whether you’re a reader, writer, or publisher, the way we create and consume books within the book industry has a bigger environmental impact than most of us realize. Did you know that more than 30 million...

In the dynamic world of publishing, authors face a pivotal choice between self-publishing and traditional publishing. While self-publishing offers unparalleled creative control and the potential for higher royalties, it comes with its own set of challenges and risks. Traditional publishing, facilitated by established publishing houses, provides significant support in editing,...

Self-publishing has revolutionized the book industry, offering authors unprecedented control and creative freedom over their work. Unlike traditional publishing, self-publishing allows writers to retain their rights, set their own schedules, and receive a larger share of the profits. This approach has democratized the publishing world, enabling countless writers to share...

Talk with us!
Talk with us!